Here's a list of where to find the best ice cream on Cape Cod, Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket. Many ice cream places on Cape Cod and the islands are seasonal, we recommend you call before you go during the off season!
| Store Name | Address | Town | Phone |
| Bailey's Ice Cream | 14 W Main St. | Hyannis | 508-790-9703 |
| Ben & Bills Chocolate Emporium | 209 Main St. | Falmouth | 508-548-7878 |
| Ben & Jerry's | 352 Main St. | Hyannis | 508-790-0910 |
| Ben & Jerry's | Rte 6 | North Eastham | 508-255-2817 |
| Ben & Jerry's | 258 Commercial St. | Provincetown | 508-487-3360 |
| Blondie's Ice Cream | 928 Rte. 28 | South Yarmouth | 508-398-0188 |
| Brigham's Ice Cream | 769 Iyannough Rd. | Hyannis | 508-790-2374 |
| Buffy's Homemade Ice Cream | 456 Main St. | Chatham | 508-945-5990 |
| Cape Cod Creamery | 5 Theater Colony Rd. | South Yarmouth | 508-398-8400 |
| Captain Frosty's | 219 Rte 6A | Dennis | 508-385-8548 |
| Cataumet Scoops | 1370 Rte 28A | Cataumet | 508-564-5355 |
| Chad's Ice Cream | 4075 Falmouth Rd. | Cotuit | 508-428-1048 |
| Cobies | 3260 Main St. | Brewster | 508-896-7021 |
| Dairy Queen | 917 Rte. 28 | South Yarmouth | 508-394-9535 |
| Dippin' Dots | 769 Iyannough Rd. | Hyannis | 508-862-2322 |
| Emack & Bolio's | Rte 6A | Orleans | 508-255-5844 |
| Eulinda's Ice Cream | 634 West Falmouth Hwy. | Falmouth | |
| Four Seas Ice Cream | 360 South Main St. | Centerville | 508-775-1394 |
| Friendly's | 1090 Iyannough Rd. | Hyannis | 508-771-8145 |
| Friendly's | 11 Main St. | West Harwich | 508-432-6388 |
| Hallet's Store | 139 Main St. | Yarmouth Port | 508-362-3362 |
| Highland Creamery | 316 Rte 6 | Truro | 508-487-3435 |
| Hot Chocolate Sparrow | 5 Old Colony Way | Orleans | 508-240-2230 |
| Ice Cream Café | 5 South Orleans Rd. | Orleans | 508-240-0003 |
| Ice Cream Sandwich | 66 Rte 6A | Sandwich | 508-888-7237 |
| Ice Cream Smuggler | 716 Main St. | Dennis | 508-385-5307 |
| Jerry's Seafood & Dairy Freeze | 654 Rte. 28 | West Yarmouth | 508-775-9752 |
| Kandy Korner | 474 Main St. | Hyannis | 508-771-5313 |
| Katie's Homemade Ice Cream | 570 Main St. | Hyannis | 508-771-6889 |
| Kream N Kone | Rte 28 | West Dennis | 508-394-0808 |
| Krista K's Ice Cream | 882 Main St. | West Dennis | 508-398-6569 |
| Lewis Brothers Homemade Ice Cream | 310 Commercial St. | Provincetown | 508-487-1436 |
| Lil' Caboose Ice Cream | 1279 Rte. 28 | South Yarmouth | 508-398-1848 |
| Nauset Ice Cream | 4550 State Hwy | Eastham | 508-240-2649 |
| Ojala Farm | 1955 Main St. | West Barnstable | 508-632-0100 |
| Pies A La Mode | 352 Main St. | Falmouth | 508-540-8777 |
| Polar Cave Ice Cream Parlor | 22 Falmouth Rd. | Mashpee | 508-477-5553 |
| Schoolhouse Ice Cream & Yogurt | Rte 28 | Harwich Port | 508-432-7355 |
| Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream | 326 East Falmouth Hwy. | East Falmouth | 508-457-1060 |
| Somerset Creamery | 1268 Rte 28A | Cataumet | 508-563-3430 |
| Sundae School | 387 Lower County Rd. | Dennis Port | 508-349-9122 |
| Sundae School | 594 Main St. | Harwich Port | 508-430-2444 |
| Sundae School | 210 Main St | East Orleans | 508-255-5473 |
| Whistle Shop | 435 Shore Rd. | Bourne | 508-759-8958 |
| Good Ship Lollipop | 61 Circuit Ave | Oak Bluffs | 508-693-0326 |
| Arnold's Lobster & Clam Bar | Rte 6 | North Eastham | 508-255-2575 |
| Wellfleet Dairy Bar & Grill | Rte 6 | South Wellfleet | 508-349-0278 |